There are currently three varieties of Goetze’s Caramel Creams. Each has a different name, which is kind of confusing. The plain vanilla variety is called Caramel Creams (though people often call them Bull’s Eyes). The chocolate ones are called Bull’s Eyes and the strawberry ones are called StrawberriCreams. I’ve never seen the chocolate or strawberry versions in the tray pack (which is usually how I buy my Goetze’s), but I did find them in the pick-a-mix at Baldinger’s in Zelienople.

They all have the same cool sugar cream center, but the caramel outside is a little different.
Original: The original Caramel Cream is not really what I consider caramel. It’s not buttery and smooth, but more doughy. It tastes kind of like a plain cookie dough with a plain, sweet icing. The caramel itself isn’t particularly sticky, what really sells the candy is the cream center. There really isn’t anything else like a Goetze’s Caramel Cream. The center is cool and soft and melts away almost instantly. I usually turn my caramel creams inside out when I eat them, popping the cream onto my tongue and waiting for that to dissolve before consuming the caramel O.
Chocolate - These are wildly different tasting than the original flavor. The chocolate dough is dark and smoky, not really a creamy chocolate experience, more like a really chocolatey Tootsie Roll. The caramel cream center stands out even more in this candy because of the darkness of the caramel. I would buy more of these as a companion to my beloved originals.
Strawberry - Gah! They smell like fake strawberries and taste like it, too. The dough nature of the caramel doesn’t really lend itself to this flavor, it’s kind of like a poor imitation of strawberry shortcake, a little tart, very sweet. I had to excise these from my pick-a-mix candy as the smell was rather revolting to me. I know some folks will like these (and probably do, since they’ve been around for a while), but I’m not one of them.
All of these flavors also come in a Cow Tales version as well. Generally I prefer to buy my Caramel Creams in the tray pack, as I think they stay fresh better that way than the twisted cello wrapped candies in the pick-a-mix. (I give the caramel and chocolate varieties a 9 ... the strawberri one is probably a 3 in my book.) All varieties contain both Hydrogenated Oils and High Fructose Corn Sweetener.
Related Candies
- Caramel Apple Kisses & Caramel Creams
- Cow Tails
| Name: |
Caramel Creams: Original, Chocolate and StrawberriCream |
RATING:
-
SUPERB
-
YUMMY
-
TASTY
-
WORTH IT
-
TEMPTING
-
PLEASANT
-
BENIGN
-
UNAPPEALING
-
APPALLING
-
INEDIBLE
|
| Brand: |
Goetze's |
| Place Purchased: |
Baldinger's (Zelienople, PA) |
| Price: |
$3.00/lb |
| Size: |
.4 ounces each |
| Calories per ounce: |
106 |
| Categories: |
Chocolate, Caramel, United States |
oh i am a BIG fan of these.
but i don’t usually admit it.
Ah, I love those caramels. The originals, that is. The chocolate doesn’t interest me and I’ve never see the strawberry (thank God, because they sound revolting). I eat them the opposite way you do though. I pop the out the centre and eat the caramel first, saving that little bit of sugary bliss for last.
I was also surprised at how good the chocolate caramels were, but I have never seen the strawberry flavor. The regular caramels are a personal favorite, but they have been stale the last few times I have bought any. They seem to have a flour taste to them, but I still enjoy them.
I only ever liked the cream filling in these. The caramel just never did it for me for some reason (I think it’s the flour taste John mentioned). But sometimes I get them anyways because I love the filling so much.
I just got these in Licorice and boy are they good. You may be able to get some from Goetze’s Candy Plant in Baltimore, but they only made a limited batch. Call 1-800-free-411 for the number for Goetze (pronounced ‘Gets’) in Baltimore, MD.
different tastes for different people, I suppose. while in Iraq a few years back, I tasted my first strawberry creams and promptly ordered a couple hundred. Everyone stopped by my desk to grab a daily handful.
what on-line sites are cheapest for ordering??
The supernaturally delicate cream in the middle is totally the best part. But what I also love so very very much about Goetze’s Caramel Creams is the unorthodox texture of the caramel. You’re right - it is rather like dough. If I recall correctly, wheat flour is one of the main ingredients in the caramel and it gives it a strangely compelling, really hearty bread-like flavor. Sounds odd but it works.
The original Caramel Creams are one of my all-time favorite candies. I hadn’t had them in ages, but just got some on a trip to Dylan’s Candy Bar in NY. A sweet walk down memory lane!
I am embarrassed yet still willing to admit that I am ridiculously addicted to Caramel Creams. I love the floury taste of the caramel; I love the wonderfully confusing texture of both the caramel and the cream.
I used to love eating them inside-out, but my favorite way now is to just chomp the whole thing and enjoy the melding of texture and flavor…Delicious!
(I work in a health food store. This is one of the few I refuse to give up in my “eat whole, eat natural, eat local” food mantra. Just too good to ignore. And if this means I die early….I’ll die happy and full of delicious candy. How childish….but wonderful.)
Does anyone have a recipe for the creamy center of these caramel cream candies?
do you sell/ have the raspberry
Next entry: 2006 Independent Food Awards
Previous entry: Dubble Bubble Fluff
Trackback URL: http://www.typetive.com/trackback/848